The 200 Greatest Major League Baseball Players of All Time, 2012 Ed. 61-70

The previous ten is here.


61.Eddie Plank 1901-17 LHP Athletics
     78.2
     ERA+122
     258-164
     MVPQ=none
     IP=4500

62. Arky Vaughan SS Pirates 1932-48
      77.55
      .312/.412/.507
       OPS+136
      MVPQ=1938
       Elite=1935
       PA=7720

63. Pete Rose 1963-86 Reds/Phillies Uti
      77.4
      OPS+118
      .311/.387/.443
      MVPQ=none
      PA=15,860

64.Jeff Bagwell 1B Astros 1991-05
     77.05
      OPS+149
      .303/.414/.562
      MVPQ=1996
      Elite=1994
      PA=9400

65. Charlie Gehringer 2B Tigers 1924-42
      76.75
      OPS+124
      .294/.374/.476
      MVPQ=1936, 1937
      Elite=1934
      PA=10,200

66. Ivan Rodriguez C 1991- Rangers/Tigers 
      76.5
      OPS+106
      .293/.332/.456
      MVPQ=none
      PA=10,270

67. Roberto Clemente RF 1955-72
      75.9
      OPS+130
      .330/.376/.513
      MVPQ=none
      PA=10,200

68. Johnny Bench C 1967-83 Reds
      75.9
      OPS+126
      .276/.352/.521
       MVPQ=1974
       Elite=1972
       PA=8700

69. Paul Waner RF Pirates 1926-45
      75.4
      OPS+134
      .318/.399/.502
      MVPQ=none
      PA=10,760

70. Robin Yount 1974-93 Brewers SS/CF
      75.2
      OPS+115
      .291/.351/.453
      Inner Circle=1982
      PA=12,250
   
The last two catchers are here; Bench's cumulative value sticks him past Piazza's bat (Mike Piazza=the second best catcher in baseball history).  Pudge's bat isn't good enough to get him on either team.  Bagwell challenges at first - pretty clearly he's the new starter for the B team, given his big value advantage over Greenberg.  Gehringer's the new starter for the B team, I considered his value advantage over Robinson, but Jackie's per game advantage is still the big disparity between them.  Vaughan/Yount are on the board for shortstop - look at Vaughan's bat and per game value, he blows by Banks and is the new best shortstop we've seen.  Yount's not going to make it.  Waner and Clemente are highly comparable, there's almost no distance between them; I'll say they're the new B teamers in right.  Neither Rose or Plank makes it.

 Team One

 C Bench 
    Piazza

    
1B Mize

     McGwire

     

2B Robinson

      Grich

SS  Vaughan
      Banks

      

3B Allen

      Santo

LF Delahanty

     Jackson

CF Hamilton

      Edmonds

RF Ramirez 

     Heilmann

     

 P Walsh

    Rivera

    Hubbell(L)

    Clarkson

    Newhouser(L)

    Feller

    Halladay

    Marichal

    

Uti Caruthers

Team 2

C Dickey
    Carter

1B Bagwell 
    Greenberg
     


2B  Gehringer
      Carew

      

     

SS Boudreau
     Larkin
     

 
 3B Rolen
      Molitor


LF Flick


RF Waner
      Clemente

     

P Brown

   Schilling

   Ford
   Drysdale

   Palmer
   Smoltz

DH Martinez