Part I of the full player rankings explains Total Value and the methodology behind this, it can be found here. There is no DH ranking, so those guys gotta go someplace. Why is guy X here and not in right? Just 'cause.
1. Willie Mays 1948-73 Giants 172.5
2. Ty Cobb 1905-28 Tigers 162.1
3. Tris Speaker 1907-28 Indians/Red Sox 158
4. Mickey Mantle 1951-68 Yankees 140.7
5. Mike Trout 2011- Angels 112.7
6. Joe DiMaggio 1936-51 Yankees 105.8
7. Ken Griffey 1989-2010 Mariners/Reds 102.4
8. Oscar Charleston 1915-41 Crawfords/ABCs 92.3
9. Carlos Beltran 1998-2017 Royals/Mets 88.1
10. Billy Hamilton 1888-1901 Beaneaters/Phillies 82.2
11. Duke Snider 1947-64 Dodgers 81.2
12. Jim Edmonds 1993-2010 Cards/Angels 80.7
13. Cristobel Torriente 1913-32 American Giants 77.3
14. Reggie Smith 1966-82 Red Sox/Dodgers 76.1
15. Richie Ashburn 1948-62 Phillies 75.5
16. Turkey Stearnes 1923-40 Stars/American Giants 72.8
17. Andruw Jones 1996-2012 Braves 72.6
18. Larry Doby 1942-59 Indians/Eagles 71.7
19. Kirby Puckett 1984-95 Twins 71.5
20. Kenny Lofton 1991-2007 Indians 71
21. Max Carey 1910-29 Pirates 70.7
22. Chet Lemon 1975-90 Tigers/White Sox 69.9
23. Lenny Dykstra 1985-96 Phillies/Mets 67.9
24. Andre Dawson 1976-96 Expos/Cubs 67.7
25. Jimmy Wynn 1963-77 Astros 66.6
26. Bernie Williams 1991-2006 Yankees 64.4
27. Fred Lynn 1974-90 Red Sox 60.9
28. Willie Davis 1960-79 Dodgers 60.2
29. Brett Butler 1981-97 Dodgers 60
