Last team here.
Through 2016
New project, all time rosters for each team. WAR is B-Ref+Davenport. Other numbers are OPS+/ERA+.
The structure of all of these teams will be the same, 7 bench players (well, 6 for AL teams since they have a DH) with someone able to backup every position. 10 pitchers, a legitimate bullpen arm as closer.
C Gene Tenace 1977-80 19.2 136
1B Adrian Gonzalez 2006-10 25.45 141
2B Bip Roberts 1986-91, 94-5 13.75 106
SS Ozzie Smith 1978-81 13.4 66
3B Ken Caminiti 1995-98 20.4 147
LF (CF) Dave Winfield 1973-80 29.3 134
CF Gene Richards 1977-83 16.55 113
RF Tony Gwynn 1982-01 70.55 132
3B Chase Headley 2007-14 20.3 113
1B Phil Nevin 1999-05 18.3 129
RF Brian Giles 2003-09 19.8 122
LF Ryan Klesko 2000-06 16 134
C Benito Santiago 1986-92 17.35 95
2B Roberto Alomar 1988-90 12.7 103
SS Garry Templeton 1982-91 12.55 77
P Jake Peavy 2002-09 31.7 119
P Andy Ashby 1993-99, 04 21.95 112
P Randy Jones 1973-80 22.1 104
P Andy Benes 1989-95 21.65 109
P Greg Harris 1988-93 16.7 128
Cl Trevor Hoffman 1993-08 45.9 146
P Heath Bell 2007-11 17.85 150
P Ed Whitson 1983-84, 86-91 16.35 99
P Eric Show 1981-90 16.05 101
P Bruce Hurst 1989-93 15.95 113