The guts of this post are here. You can also find my 10 best WWE matches of 2011 at that post.
The best wrestler in the world in 2011 - Kotaro Suzuki
1. Kotaro v. Nakajima - March, NOAH.
2. Go v. Sugiura - July, NOAH.
3. Sugiura v. Morishima - December, 2010. NOAH
4. Go v. Akiyama - August, NOAH
5. Akiyama v. Suwama - October, All Japan
6. Suwama v. Nagata - June, All Japan
7. Nagata v. Tanaka - March, Zero One
8. Kotaro/Aoki v. Kenta/Kanemaru - August, NOAH
9. Kotaro v. Nakajima -September, NOAH
10. Kotaro v. Ishimori - March, NOAH
11. Richards v. Strong - April, ROH
12. Richards v. Edwards - June, ROH
13. Richards v. Daniels - March, ROH
14. Minoru v. Kondo - March, All Japan
15. Young Bucks v. Generico/Ricochet - April, PWG
16. American Wolves v. Haas/Benjamin - April, ROH
17. Kotaro/Aoki v. Kenta/Kanemaru - July, NOAH
18. Ibushi v. Taguchi - June, New Japan
19. Tanahashi v. Naito - October, New Japan
20. Tanahashi v. Goto - June, New Japan
21. Tanahashi v. Nagata - April, New Japan
22. Kenta v. Marufuji - December, 2010 - NOAH
23. Devitt v. Ibushi - January - New Japan
24. Pac v. Tozawa - March, DGUSA
25. Go v. Miyahara - February, Kensuke Office
You can find an additional 20 matches of this quality here.