Part of a series. Previous post is here. Updated through end of 2019 season. Here's my all time Colts roster.
QB Peyton Manning
Johnny Unitas
Bert Jones
Andrew Luck
RB Edgerrin James
RB Lenny Moore
Lydell Mitchell
Alan Ameche
Tom Matte
WR Marvin Harrison
WR Ray Berry
Reggie Wayne
Roger Carr
TY Hilton
TE John Mackey
Dallas Clark
C Jeff Saturday
G Alex Sandusky
G Art Spinney
T Jim Parker
T Tarik Glenn
OL Bob Vogel
OL Ryan Diem
OL Dick Szymanski
DE Gino Marchetti
DT Art Donovan
DT Fred Miller
DE Dwight Freeney
DL Robert Mathis
DL Ordell Braase
DL Billy Ray Smith
DL Donnell Thompson
DL Bubba Smith
OLB Don Shinnick
MLB Mike Curtis
OLB Duane Bickett
LB Bill Pellington
LB Ted Hendricks
LB Stan White
LB Jeff Herrod
LB Barry Krauss
LB Gary Brackett
CB Bobby Boyd
S Jerry Logan
S Rick Volk
CB Eugene Daniel
DB Andy Nelson
DB Lenny Lyles
DB Bruce Laird
DB Antoine Bethea
DB Jason Belser
PK Adam Vinatieri
P Rohn Stark