Part I of the full player rankings explains Total Value and the methodology behind this, it can be found here. Some of these guys were like half catchers, they're here anyway. First basemen tomorrow.
27 catchers in MLB history have a Total Value of 60+.
1. Johnny Bench 1967-83 Reds 110.7
2. Gary Carter 1974-92 Expos/Mets 103.2
3. Ivan Rodriguez 1991-2011 Rangers/Tigers 102.5
4. Yogi Berra 1946-65 Yankees 100.7
5. Carlton Fisk 1969-93 White Sox/Red Sox 95.8
6. Bill Dickey 1928-46 Yankees 93.2
7. Josh Gibson 1930-46 Grays/Crawfords 85.3
8. Gabby Hartnett 1922-41 Cubs 82.1
9. Mike Piazza 1992-2007 Mets/Dodgers 81.4
10. Yadier Molina 2004-22 Cards 79.5
11. Buck Ewing 1880-97 Giants 77.6
12. Buster Posey 2009-21 Giants 76.9
13. Mickey Cochrane 1925-37 Athletics 76.7
14. Thurman Munson 1969-79 Yankees 75.4
15. Joe Torre 1960-77 Braves/Cards 74.7
16. Joe Mauer 2004-18 Twins 73.2
17. King Kelly 1878-93 White Stockings/Beaneaters 72.5
18. Gene Tenace 1969-83 A's 72.2
19. Charlie Bennett 1878-93 Wolverines/Beaneaters 69.9
20. Ted Simmons 1968-88 Cards/Brewers 68.9
21. Roy Campanella 1937-57 Dodgers 68.2
22. Lance Parrish 1977-95 Tigers 65
23. Russell Martin 2006-19 Dodgers 64.8
24. Wally Schang 1913-31 Athletics/Yankees 64.6
25. Brian Downing 1973-92 Angels/White Sox 64.2
26. Bill Freehan 1961-76 Tigers 62.4
27. Darrell Porter 1971-87 Brewers/Cards 62.3
