Using the best WAR calculation that exists, B-Ref+Davenport, these are the best players from the 2016 MLB season.
C B.Posey SFG 5.6
J.Lucroy Mil/Tex 4.8
W.Ramos Wash 4.7
Y.Molina StL 3.5
JT Realmuto Mia 3.5
Y.Grandal LA 3.5
1B A.Rizzo Chi 7.45
F.Freeman Atl 6.9
M.Cabrera Det 6.35
J.Votto Cin 5.9
P.Goldschmidt Ari 5.45
2B R.Cano Sea 7.3
J.Altuve Hou 6
I.Kinsler Det 5.7
DJ LeMahieu Col 5.3
B.Dozier Min 5.15
SS F.Lindor Cle 5.85
C.Correa Hou 5.1
C.Seager LA 4.9
J.Villar Mil 4.85
A.Russell Chi 4.8
3B K.Bryant Chi 8.2 NL MVP
K.Seager Sea 7.05
N.Arenado Col 6.9
J.Donaldson Tor 6.45
M.Machado Bal 6.15
LF C.Yelich Mia 4.65
R.Braun Mil 4.4
S.Marte Pit 4.35
Y.Cespedes NYM 4.05
B.Gardner NYY 3.65
CF M.Trout LAA 9.2 AL MVP
O.Herrera Phi 4.65
C.Blackmon Col 4.5
D.Fowler Chi 4.35
J.Bradley Bos 4.35
RF M.Betts Bos 8.5
A.Eaton CWS 6.4
G.Springer Hou 5.65
B.Harper Wash 3.25
S.Piscotty StL 3.2
DH D.Ortiz Bos 5.55
N.Cruz Sea 4.9
E.Encarnacion Tor 3.65
SP N.Syndergaard NYM 6.6 - NL Cy
M.Scherzer Wash 6.55
J.Verlander Det 6.3 - AL Cy
C.Martinez StL 6.3
C.Kershaw LAD 6.25
M.Bumgarner SFG 6.15
C.Kluber Cle 5.75
T.Roark Wash 5.7
J.Cueto SFG 5.55
J.Lester Chi 5.55
J.Fernandez Mia 5.5
J.Quintana CWS 5.35
C.Sale CWS 5.2
K.Hendricks Chi 5.2
R.Porcello Bos 5
M.Tanaka NYY 4.9
J.Teheran Atl 4.85
R.Hill Oak/LAD 4.55
M.Fullmer Det 4.5
D.Pomeranz SD/Bos 4.5
Relievers
Z.Britton Bal 5.4
A.Miller NYY 5.15
M.Melancon Was/Pit 5.05
A.Chapman NYY/Chi 4.3
K.Jansen LAD 4.15
A.Colome TB 3.65
B.Ziegler Ari/Bos 3.6
S.H Oh StL 3.55
J.Familia NYM 3.25
D.Phelps Mia 3.25
