AL East
1. NYY 86
2. Tampa 84-WC
3. Baltimore 82
4. Toronto 82
5. Boston 81
AL Central
1. KC 86
2. Det 83-WC
3. Cle 81
4. CWS 79
5. Minn 79
AL West
1. Hou 84
2. LAA 82
3. Sea 81
4. Tex 80
5. Oak 77
NL East
1. Wash 90
2. NYM 82
3. Mia 74
3. Atl 74
5. Phil 65
NL Central
1. St Louis 94
2. Chi 87-WC
3. Pitt 84
4. Cin 77
5. Mil 73
NL West
1. LAD 92
2. SFG 85 - WC
3. SD 80
4. Ari 75
5. Col 74
Here's my current selection for All Star Game Rosters.
Each league has 34 players. There have to be at least 5 starters/3 relievers for each league. Each league had 13 active pitchers last year, so I'll make that my target. Both leagues use a DH. Every team needs to be represented. The number is my WAR number (B-Ref+Davenport).
AL Starters
C S.Vogt Oak 2.7
1B M.Cabrera Det 2.55
2B J.Kipnis Cle 2.85
SS J.Iglesias Det 1.9
3B J.Donaldson Tor 3.75-MVP
LF Y.Cespedes Det 2.5
CF M.Trout LAA 3.65
RF N.Cruz Sea 3.1
DH J.Bautista Tor 1.9
AL Bench
C R.Martin Tor 2.55
1B M.Teixeira NYY 1.95
2B D.Pedroia Bos 2.55
2B B.Dozier Min 2.5
2B I.Kinsler Det 2.4
SS B.Miller Sea 1.6
3B M.Moustakas KC 2.4
3B M.Machado Balt 2.2
OF A.Gordon KC 2.15
OF L.Cain KC 2.3
OF K.Kiermaier TB 2.15
OF A.Jones Balt 2.15
AL Pitchers
SP S.Gray Oak 4.15-Cy
SP D.Keuchel Hou 3.65
SP C.Archer TB 3.1
SP F.Hernandez Sea 2.6
SP M.Pelfrey Min 2.4
SP J.Odorizzi TB 2.2
SP C. Sale CWS 2
SP J.Chavez Oak 1.95
SP N.Martinez Tex 1.85
RP A.Miller NYY 2.05
RP W.Davis KC 1.9
RP G.Perkins Min 1.85
RP D.Betances NYY 1.85
NL Starters
C B.Posey SFG 3
1B P.Goldschmidt Ari 3.95
2B D.Gordon Mia 3.2
SS B.Crawford SFG 3.05
3B. T.Frazier Cin 3.05
LF J.Upton SD 2.35
CF AJ Pollock Ari 2.8
RF B.Harper Wash 4.45-MVP
DH A.Gonzalez LAD 3.1
NL Bench
C D.Norris SD 1.55
1B J.Votto Cin 2.8
1B A.Rizzo Chi 2.6
2B J.Panik SFG 2.35
2B DJ LeMahieu Col 2.1
SS J.Peralta StL 2.65
3B N.Arenada Col 2.65
OF N.Aoki SFG 1.75
OF A.McCutchen Pit 1.7
OF J.Pederson LAD 2.1
OF G.Stanton Mia 2.4
NL Pitchers
SP M.Scherzer Wash 3.55-Cy
SP G.Cole Pit 3.05
SP Z.Greinke LAD 2.8
SP S.Miller Atl 2.55
SP AJ Burnett Pit2.55
SP M.Wacha StL 2.45
SP J.DeGrom NYM 2.4
SP C.Hamels Phi 2.35
SP A.Harang Phi 2.25
SP J.Hammel Chi 2.1
SP J.Cueto Cin 2.1
RP T.Rosenthal StL 2.4
RP D.Storen Wash 2.1
RP F.Rodriguez Mil 1.7