-The qualifier for the MLB Network list eliminated Cy Young given his pre 1900 career. MLB Network list is first, mine's second. My top 200 of all time is here.
MLB Network List:
1. Johnson
2. Maddux
3. Alexander
3. Mathewson
5. Clemens
6. Seaver
7. Martinez
8. Palmer
9. Gibson
My List:
1. Johnson
2. Clemens
3. Young
4. Alexander
5. Maddux
6. Martinez
7. Mathewson
8. Gibson
9. Walsh
If I had the same restriction as the 19th century pitchers that MLB Network used, Seaver would be my 9th, and everyone would slide up. I'm gonna guess Clemens got bumped back on the MLB list by the morality police. Ed Walsh had a career ERA+ of 146, so you can decide if he was better than Palmer (126).
