The final fan pick is still left. Here's where we stand.
Votto, Turner definitely should have made the team. I also would have picked Granderson, but he'd go if that third catcher was needed.
All Star teams have ridiculous numbers of relievers, this is no exception. Hamels winds up getting left off at the expense of Papelbon. Cueto lost his for Chapman, which is not that big a deal.
All should make the team.
The AL. Miller and Gardner should be starting and neither made the team. Miller's a small crime, best of a bad lot - but Gardner should have made the team. Dozier should have definitely made the team. I'd have Bogaerts over Iglesias, but again, shortstops. And then backup outfielders - Kiermaier, Pillar, Cespedes over Holt, Martinez, Tex. None of those changes are dire, but Kiermaier really should have made this team.
Seven Relievers! Awful. I had Price just missing the team; Gallardo's having a better year and should make it - I'd take four relievers off the roster and replace them with starters, but outside of Gallardo none of the left out starters has a real beef. Even Gallardo can't say he got screwed.