The number is my preferred WAR calculation, combining B-Ref and Davenport, which I think is the best cross-section for historical lists. If Prospectus ever updates their WARP numbers for pre-1950 seasons I'll probably add those and Fangraphs and make a new calculation.
These are the numbers through 2012; no one joined the list since last year, the first year I've done an update where the full 200 held. At the bottom is the current total of a number of notable active players.
There are currently 27 members of the 100 WAR club, Pujols will join after the 2013 season. He has an outside chance to catch ARod this year for career value among active players.
1.
Babe Ruth
180
2.
Barry Bonds
172.6
3.
Willie Mays
149.95
4.
Walter
Johnson 145.15
5.
Ty Cobb
141.35
6.
Roger
Clemens 138.6
7. Hank Aaron 135.5
8. Cy Young 133
9. Honus Wagner 131.05
10. Stan Musial 124.75
11. Tris Speaker 122.1
12. Ted Williams 118.85
13. Rickey Henderson 116.7
14. Rogers Hornsby 116.6
15. Eddie Collins 115.95
16. Greg Maddux 110.9
17. Mike Schmidt 109.05
18. Lou Gehrig 109
19. Tom Seaver 108.8
20. Pete Alexander 108.5
21. Frank Robinson 106.25
22. Nap Lajoie 105.95
23. Alex Rodriguez 105
24. Warren Spahn 102.55
25. Mel Ott 102.55
26. Mickey Mantle 102.4
27. Joe Morgan 101.55
28. Albert Pujols 99.25
29. Cap Anson 98
30. Randy Johnson 97.65
31. Cal Ripken 96.4
32.
Christy
Mathewson 95.25
33.
Eddie
Mathews 95.15
34.
Bert
Blyleven 91.3
35.
Steve
Carlton 91.2
36.
Phil Niekro
90.95
37.
Gaylord
Perry 90.9
38.
Bob Gibson
89.65
39.
Nolan Ryan
88.05
40.
Roger Connor
87.9
41.
Jimmie Foxx
87.4
42.
Lefty Grove
85.4
43.
Robin
Roberts 85.2
44.
Wade Boggs
85.1
45.
Al Kaline 85
46.
George Davis
84.75
47.
Chipper
Jones 83.15
48.
Ken Griffey
82.95
49.
Tom Glavine
82.8
50.
Dan
Brouthers 82.55
51.
Kid Nichols
82.45
52.
Mike Mussina
82
53.
Carl
Yastrzemski 81.75
54.
George Brett
81.6
55.
Ferguson
Jenkins 81.15
56.
Ozzie Smith
79.9
57.
Pedro
Martinez 79.55
58.
Joe DiMaggio
79.5
59.
Frank Thomas
78.45
60.
Bill Dahlen
78.45
61.
Eddie Plank
78.2
62.
Arky Vaughan
77.55
63.
Pete Rose
77.4
64.
Jeff Bagwell
77.05
65.
Charlie
Gehringer 76.75
66.
Ivan
Rodriguez 76.5
67.
Roberto
Clemente 75.9
68.
Johnny Bench
75.9
69.
Paul Waner
75.4
70.
Jim Thome
75.3
71.
Robin Yount
75.2
72.
John Smoltz
74.8
73.
Bobby Grich
74.7
74.
Barry Larkin
74.45
75.
Ed Delahanty
73.85
76.
Don Sutton
73.65
77.
Paul Molitor
73.1
78.
Frankie
Frisch 72.4
79.
Don Drysdale
72.25
80.
Tony Gwynn
72.15
81.
Gary Carter
71.95
82.
Luke Appling
71.95
83.
Rod Carew
71.7
84.
Curt
Schilling 71.55
85.
Kevin Brown
70.7
86.
Lou Whitaker
70.5
87.
Alan
Trammell 70.35
88.
Johnny Mize
70.25
89.
Scott Rolen
70
90.
Gary
Sheffield 69.45
91.
Jim Edmonds
69.35
92.
Tim Raines
69.1
93.
Robby Alomar
69.05
94.
Edgar
Martinez 68.95
95.
Manny
Ramirez 68.75
96.
Jeff Kent
68.6
97.
Derek Jeter
68.45
98.
Ron Santo
68.3
99.
Craig Biggio
68.15
100.
Carl Hubbell
67.8
101.
Fred Clarke
67.5
102.
Rick
Reuschel 67.2
103.
Sam Crawford
67.15
104.
Ryne
Sandberg 67.1
105.
John
Clarkson 67.05
106.
Willie
McCovey 67
107.
Red Ruffing
66.9
108.
Reggie
Jackson 66.5
109.
Bob Feller
66.5
110.
Roy Halladay
66.4
111.
Jim Palmer
66.4
112.
Billy
Hamilton 66.2
113.
Carlton Fisk
65.8
114.
Joe Cronin
65.55
115.
Larry Walker
65.4
116.
Yogi Berra
65.3
117.
Carlos
Beltran 65.05
118.
Mark McGwire
64.9
119.
Tim Keefe
64.85
120.
Bob
Caruthers 64.55
121.
Todd Helton
64.5
122.
Juan
Marichal 64.45
123.
Eddie Murray
64.3
124.
Willie
Randolph 63.75
125.
Dwight Evans
63.7
126.
Keith
Hernandez 63.6
127.
Ted Lyons
63.45
128.
Rafael
Palmeiro 63.4
129.
Pee Wee
Reese 63.3
130.
Jack
Glasscock 63.3
131.
Brooks
Robinson 63.25
132.
Tommy John
62.65
133.
Bill Dickey
62.45
134.
David Cone
62.25
135.
Mike Piazza
61.95
136.
Lou Boudreau
61.95
137.
Sammy Sosa
61.9
138.
Jackie
Robinson 61.6
139.
Harry Heilmann
61.6
140.
Ed Walsh
61.55
141.
Reggie Smith
61.55
142.
Dennis
Eckersley 61.4
143.
Gabby
Hartnett 61.4
144.
Mariano
Rivera 61.35
145.
Bobby
Wallace 61.35
146.
Ernie Banks
61.3
147.
Frank Tanana
61
148.
Old Hoss
Radbourn 61
149.
Buck Ewing
60.7
150.
Bobby Abreu
60.65
151.
Hal
Newhouser 60.45
152.
Andre Dawson
60.2
153.
Early Wynn
60.15
154.
Billy Herman
60.1
155.
Chuck Finley
60.1
156.
Dick Allen
60.05
157.
Luis Tiant
59.8
158.
Will Clark
59.7
159.
Darrell
Evans 59.4
160.
Whitey Ford
59.2
161.
Wee Willie
Keeler 59.15
162.
Jake Beckley
58.95
163.
CC Sabathia
58.85
164.
Vladimir
Guerrero 58.8
165.
Tim Hudson
58.7
166.
Bobby Doerr
58.55
167.
John Olerud
58.5
168.
Joe Gordon
58.45
169.
Ducky
Medwick 58.25
170.
Jim Bunning
58.25
171.
Richie
Ashburn 57.9
172.
Joe Jackson
57.85
173.
Elmer Flick
57.85
174.
Duke Snider
57.7
175.
Andy
Pettitte 57.65
176.
King Kelly
57.55
177.
Bid McPhee
57.45
178.
Andruw Jones
57.35
179.
Jimmy Wynn
57.25
180.
Jason Giambi
57.2
181.
Amos Rusie
56.75
182.
Al Simmons
56.7
183.
Dazzy Vance
56.4
184.
Lance
Berkman 56.35
185.
Harmon
Killebrew 56.05
186.
Kenny Lofton
55.95
187.
Stan Hack
55.9
188.
Graig
Nettles 55.5
189.
Joe Torre
55.7
190.
Ken Boyer
55.7
191.
Jim O’Rourke
55.7
192.
Willie
Stargell 55.45
193.
Buddy Bell
55.4
194.
Bret
Saberhagen 54.95
195.
Bernie
Williams 54.85
196.
Hank
Greenberg 54.6
197.
Jesse
Burkett 54.4
198.
Zack Wheat
54.25
199.
Robin
Ventura 54.2
200.
Bobby Bonds
53.85
Robinson
Cano 38.5
Mark
Teixeira 46.6
Curtis
Granderson 33.45
Evan
Longoria 28.25
Ichiro
Suzuki 51
Jose Reyes
30.3
Mark Buehrle
48.35
Dustin
Pedroia 27.65
David Ortiz
40.25
Prince
Fielder 26
Miguel
Cabrera 44.65
Justin
Verlander 36.3
Torii Hunter
42.2
Jake Peavy
40.2
Joe Mauer
40.05
Ian Kinsler
30.05
Adrian
Beltre 52.3
Josh
Hamilton 24.8
Josh Beckett
33.7
Carl
Crawford 34.95
Johnny Damon
46.05
Roy Oswalt
52.8
Zack Greinke
32.05
Dan Haren
33.6
Mike Trout
9.95
Jered Weaver
32.35
Felix
Hernandez 35.15
Bryce Harper
4.95
Steven
Strasburg 6.2
Ryan
Zimmerman 29.2
Jason
Heyward 11.7
Cole Hamels
31.05
Cliff Lee
37.05
Jimmy
Rollins 41.3
Chase Utley 51.8
Johan
Santana 53.15
David Wright
42.1
Hanley
Ramirez 29.95
Giancarlo
Stanton 14.05
Brandon
Phillips 21.4
Joey Votto
27.25
Matt
Holliday 37.85
Ryan Braun
36.3
Andrew
McCutcheon 18.5
Troy
Tulowitzki 30.85
Matt Kemp
20.7
Clayton
Kershaw 25.1
Matt Cain 32.65
Tim Lincecum
22.9
Buster Posey
18.5
Pablo
Sandoval 16.3
