Last team here.
Through 2016
New project, all time rosters for each team. WAR is B-Ref+Davenport. Other numbers are OPS+/ERA+.
The structure of all of these teams will be the same, 7 bench players (well, 6 for AL teams since they have a DH) with someone able to backup every position. 10 pitchers, a legitimate bullpen arm as closer.
C Yogi Berra (1946-63) 64.55 125
1B Lou Gehrig (1923-39) 105.25 179
2B Willie Randolph (1976-88) 58.15 105
SS Derek Jeter (1995-2014) 74.25 115
3B (SS) Alex Rodriguez (2004-16) 57.3 136
LF Roy White (1965-79) 45.5 121
CF (RF) Mickey Mantle (1951-68) 99.95 172
RF (LF) Babe Ruth (1920-34) 136.4 209
DH Joe DiMaggio (1936-51) 76.7 155
C Bill Dickey (1928-46) 64.45 127
CF Bernie Williams (1991-2006) 58.05 125
C Jorge Posada (1995-2011) 53.1 121
2B Robinson Cano (2005-13) 51.6 126
3B Graig Nettles (1973-83) 43.1 114
1B Don Mattingly (1982-95) 48.9 127
P Whitey Ford (1950-67) 57.3 133
P Andy Pettitte (1995-03, 07-13) 57.9 115
P Ron Guidry (1975-88) 51.6 119
P Red Ruffing (1930-46) 51.35 119
P Bob Shawkey (1915-27) 41.2 117
Cl Mariano Rivera (1995-13) 90.1 205
P Mel Stottlemyre (1964-74) 41.65 112
P Lefty Gomez (1930-42) 40.4 125
P Mike Mussina (2001-08) 38.5 114
P Dave Righetti (1979-90) 32.35 127
