The first list is the MLB Network "shredder" projection for the ten best first basemen for the 2017 season, the second is the Bill James list. Finally, me - and I take the list out to 15. I'm going to do two passes at this, one now, the second just before the start of the season. Number is my WAR projection, largely just included for my purposes.
Catchers are here.
MLB Network
1. P. Goldschmidt Ari
2. M. Cabrera Det
3. J. Votto Cin
4. A. Rizzo Chi
5. F. Freeman Atl
6. E. Encarnacion Cle
7. M. Carpenter StL
8. B. Belt SFG
9. C. Davis Balt
10. J. Abreu CWS
Bill James
1. J. Votto
2. P. Goldschmidt
3. M. Cabrera
4. A. Rizzo
5. F. Freeman
6. H. Ramirez Bos
7. E. Encarnacion
8. B. Belt
9. J. Abreu
10. W. Myers SD
Jividen
1. P.Goldschmidt Ari 5.6
2. M.Cabrera Det 5.2
3. A.Rizzo Chi 5.2
3. A.Rizzo Chi 5.2
4. J.Votto Cin 4.65
5. F.Freeman Atl 4.45
6. J.Abreu CWS 3.75
7. B.Belt SFG 3.7
8. C.Santana Cle 2.75
8. C.Santana Cle 2.75
9. M.Carpenter StL 2.6
10. A.Gonzalez LAD 2.5
11. S.Pearce Tor 2.4
12. C.Davis Balt 2.2
10. A.Gonzalez LAD 2.5
11. S.Pearce Tor 2.4
12. C.Davis Balt 2.2
13. W.Myers SD 2.05
14. E.Hosmer KC 1.6
15. D.Valencia Sea 1.55
-J.Mauer Min 1.3
-J.Bour Mia 1.25
15. D.Valencia Sea 1.55
-J.Mauer Min 1.3
-J.Bour Mia 1.25
-J.Bell Pit 1.15
-M.Napoli Tex 1.1
-G.Bird NYY 1.05
-E.Thames Mil .95
-L.Duda NYM .9
-L.Morrison TB .6
-CJ Cron LAA .55
-I.Desmond Col .5
-Y.Alonso Oak .4
-T.Joseph Phi .4
-M.Moreland Bos .15
-R.Zimmerman Wash .1
-Y. Gurriel Hou 0
-G.Bird NYY 1.05
-E.Thames Mil .95
-L.Duda NYM .9
-L.Morrison TB .6
-CJ Cron LAA .55
-I.Desmond Col .5
-Y.Alonso Oak .4
-T.Joseph Phi .4
-M.Moreland Bos .15
-R.Zimmerman Wash .1
-Y. Gurriel Hou 0