AL East.
1. Boston 84
2. NYY 84
3. Tampa 83
4. Baltimore 80
5. Toronto 78
AL Central
1. KC 86
2. Det 85-WC
3. CWS 80
4. Cle 79
5. Minn 77
AL West
1. Hou 86
2. LAA 84-WC
3. Sea 83
4. Oak 77
5. Tex 75
NL East
1. Wash 94
2. NYM 83
3. Mia 74
3. Atl 73
5. Phil 69
NL Central
1. St Louis 93
2. Chi 86-WC
3. Pitt 80
4. Cin 76
5. Mil 76
NL West
1. LAD 93
2. SFG 83 - WC
3. SD 81
4. Ari 75
5. Col 71
Here's my current selection for All Star Game Rosters.
Each league has 34 players. There have to be at least 5 starters/3 relievers for each league. Each league had 13 active pitchers last year, so I'll make that my target; I still wouldn't ever have an all star roster with more than 3 relievers. We'd need 40 players a side before I'd do that. Both leagues use a DH. Every team needs to be represented. I'm not going to pick a player from each team in this first build, but when I come back at the 60 game mark I'll set up the rosters with that requirement. The number is my WAR number (B-Ref+Davenport).
AL
C Vogt Oak 2.15, Martin Tor 2, Perez KC 1.85
1B Cabrera Det 2.2 Hosmer KC 1.65 Teixeira NYY 1.5
2B Kinsler Det 2.25, Altuve Hou 2, Kipnis Cle 1.5,
SS Simien Oak 1.4, Miller Sea 1.15,
3B Moustakas KC 2.3, Donaldson Tor 2.1, Machado 1.8 Bal
LF Brantley Cle 1.6
CF Trout LAA 2.55, Cain KC 2.35, Jones Balt 1.75
RF Cruz Sea 2.55, Reddick Oak 1.5,
DH Bautista Tor 1.15
SP Keuchel Hou 2.7
Gray Oak 2.6
Hernandez Sea 2.2
Odorizzi TB 1.65
Martinez Tex 1.55
Pineda NYY 1.4
Archer TB 1.4
Gibson Min 1.4
Lewis Tex 1.4
Bauer Cle 1.35
RP Betances NYY 1.7
Miller NYY 1.5
Davis KC 1.4
NL
C Posey SFG 2.15, Norris Was 1.4, Ramos SD 1.25
1B Gonzalez LAD 2.5, Rizzo Chi 2.15, Freeman Atl 1.2
2B Gordon 2.8 Mia, Phillips Cin 1.3,
SS Crawford 2.4 SFG, Peralta StL 1.6, Simmons Atl 1.4
3B Frazier 2 Cin, Carpenter StL 1.4, Arenado Col 1.35LF Upton SD 1.8, Peralta Ari 1.4 , Holliday 1.35 StL
CF Fowler Chi 1.3, Pederson LA 1.25,
RF Harper Was 3.7,
DH Goldschmidt Ari 2.3
SP Harang Phi 2.6
Scherzer Was 2.55
Greinke LA 2.35
Miller Atl 2.35
Burnett Pitt 2.2
Harvey NYM 2.05
Wacha StL 1.9
Lincecum SFG 1.75
Cole Pit 1.65
Hamels Phi 1.55
RP Chapman Cin 1.5
Storen Wash 1.45
Rosenthal StL 1.35