Last team here.
Through 2015
New project, all time rosters for each team. WAR is B-Ref+Davenport. Other numbers are OPS+/ERA+.
The structure of all of these teams will be the same, 7 bench players (well, 6 for AL teams since they have a DH) with someone able to backup every position. 10 pitchers, a legitimate bullpen arm as closer.
C Darren Daulton 1983-97 26.5 114
1B(3B) Dick Allen 1963-69, 75-6 37.6 153
2B Chase Utley 2003-15 60.15 122
SS Jimmy Rollins 2000-14 47.35 97
3B Mike Schmidt 1972-89 108.45 147
LF Ed Delahanty 1888-89, 91-01 65.35 153
CF Richie Ashburn 1948-59 59.7 111
RF Bobby Abreu 1998-06 46.4 139
LF Sherry Magee 1904-14 41 143
RF Johnny Callison 1960-69 37.9 122
CF Roy Thomas 1899-08, 10-11 38.95 125
LF/CF/RF Billy Hamilton 1890-95 37.3 154
1B Von Hayes 1982-91 27.45 118
C Jack Clements 1884-97 26.1 118
2B/SS Granny Hamner 1944-59 18.35 84
P Robin Roberts 1948-61 71.1 114
P Steve Carlton 1972-86 68.3 120
P Pete Alexander 1911-17, 30 60.1 140
P Cole Hamels 2006-15 46.85 124
P Curt Schilling 1992-00 37.3 126
Cl Curt Davis 1934-36 13.95 135
P Chris Short 1959-72 32.95 105
P Jim Bunning 1964-67, 70-1 31.4 122
P Curt Simmons 1947-60 25 108
P Al Orth 1895-90 24.4 109