Last team here.
Through 2016
New project, all time rosters for each team. WAR is B-Ref+Davenport. Other numbers are OPS+/ERA+.
The structure of all of these teams will be the same, 7 bench players (well, 6 for AL teams since they have a DH) with someone able to backup every position. 10 pitchers, a legitimate bullpen arm as closer.
C Jason Kendall 1996-04 37.65 108
1B Willie Stargell 1962-82 54.4 147
2B Bill Mazeroski 1956-72 44.25 84
SS Honus Wagner 1900-17 120.65 154
3B Pie Traynor 1920-37 38.95 107
LF Barry Bonds 1986-92 50.35 147
CF Max Carey 1910-26 44.45 111
RF Roberto Clemente 1955-72 81.6 130
SS Arky Vaughan 1932-41 66.45 141
LF Fred Clarke 1900-15 43.55 136
RF Paul Waner 1926-40 69.7 136
2B Claude Ritchy 1900-06 26.85 105
C Manny Sanguillen 1967-76, 78-0 25.5 105
3B/1B Richie Hebner 1968-76, 82-3 21.35 122
CF Andrew McCutchen 2009- 38.95 138
P Bob Friend 1951-65 52.35 108
P Babe Adams 1907-26 46.6 118
P Wilbur Cooper 1912-23 45.3 120
P Sam Leever 1898-10 37.6 123
P Vern Law 1950-67 33.35 101
P Roy Face 1953-68 27.9 110
P John Candelaria 1975-85, 93 32.9 117
P Rip Sewell 1938-49 28.5 109
P Deacon Phillippe 1900-11 27.65 119
P Jesse Tannehill 1897-02 27.55 127