New project, all time rosters for each team. WAR is B-Ref+Davenport. Other numbers are OPS+/ERA+.
The structure of all of these teams will be the same, 7 bench players (well, 6 for AL teams since they have a DH) with someone able to backup every position. 10 pitchers, a legitimate bullpen arm as closer.
C Buck Ewing (1883-89, 91-93) 40.95 146
1B Willie McCovey (1959-73, 77-80) 61.05 149
2B Frankie Frisch (1919-26) 35.55 116
2B Frankie Frisch (1919-26) 35.55 116
SS Travis Jackson (1922-36) 43.45 102
3B Art Devlin (1904-11) 34.4 110
LF Barry Bonds (1993-2007) 123.5 199
CF Willie Mays (1951-72) 148.15 157
RF Mel Ott (1926-47) 105.85 155
Bench
1B Roger Connor (1883-89, 91, 93-4) 56.85 161
1B Bill Terry (1923-36) 50.7 136
SS/3B Travis Jackson (1922-36) 43.45 102
SS/3B Travis Jackson (1922-36) 43.45 102
SS/3B/CF George Davis (1893-01, 03) 42.4 132
LF/RF Mike Tiernan (1887-99) 43.2 138
2B Jeff Kent (1997-02) 35.35 136
C Buster Posey (2009- 37.3 136
SP Christy Mathewson (1900-16) 99.65 136
SP Carl Hubbell (1928-43) 70.3 130
SP Juan Marichal (1960-73) 62.9 125
SP Amos Rusie (1890-98) 60.5 137
SP Mickey Welch (1882-92) 44.6 119
Cl Gary Lavelle (1974-84) 24.55 128
RP Hal Schumacher (1931-42, 46) 34.1 111
RP Gaylord Perry (1962-71) 34.85 119
RP Matt Cain (2005- 33.05 111
RP Johnny Antonelli (1954-60) 33.85 124