Part I of the full player rankings explains Total Value and the methodology behind this, it can be found here.
36 first basemen (if you know a guy is missing, he's probably at a different position, choices had to be made; I don't have a DH ranking, so those guys had to go somewhere)
1. Lou Gehrig 1923-39 Yankees 146.6
2. Albert Pujols 2001-22 Cards/Angels 127.7
3. Jimmie Foxx 1925-45 Athletics/Red Sox 119.5
4. Dan Brouthers 1879-1904 Bisons 110.6
5. Cap Anson 1871-97 Colts 109
6. Roger Connor 1880-97 Giants 106.2
7. Jeff Bagwell 1991-2005 Astros 96.8
8. Frank Thomas 1990-2008 White Sox 95.7
9. Johnny Mize 1936-53 Cards/Giants/Yankees 94.6
10. Miguel Cabrera 2003- Tigers/Marlins 91.6
11. Jim Thome 1991-2012 Indians 88
12. David Ortiz 1997-2016 Red Sox/Twins 84.6
13. Keith Hernandez 1974-90 Cards/Mets 84
14. Rafael Palmeiro 1986-2005 Rangers/Orioles 83.2
15. Eddie Murray 1977-97 Orioles 82.4
16. Joey Votto 2007 Reds 82.2
17. Hank Greenberg 1930-47 Tigers 80.4
18. Mark McGwire 1986-2001 A's/Cards 79.8
19. Willie McCovey 1959-80 Giants 79.2
20. Paul Goldschmidt 2011- DBacks/Cards 76.6
21. Willie Stargell 1962-82 Pirates 74.7
22. John Olerud 1989-2005 Jays/Mariners 74.3
23. Bill Terry 1923-36 Giants 73.4
24. Will Clark 1986-200 Giants/Rangers 73
25. Todd Helton 1997-2013 Rockies 70.2
26. Freddie Freeman 2010- Braves 69.7
27. Jake Beckley 1887-1907 Pirates/Reds 69.3
28. Fred McGriff 1986-2004 Rays/Braves/Jays 68.3
29. Tony Perez 1964-86 Reds 66.1
30. Jason Giambi 1995-2014 A's/Yankees 66
31. Frank Chance 1898-1914 Cubs 65.6
32. Norm Cash 1958-74 Tigers 64.8
33. Gil Hodges 1943-63 Dodgers 60.8
34. George Sisler 1915-30 Browns 60.6
35. Carlos Delgado 1993-2009 Jays 60.3
36. Mark Teixeira 2003-16 Yankees/Rangers 60.2
